People living in so-called energy communities are usually enthusiastic about producing their own renewable energy, but certain complaints and frustrations keep coming up, the latest EU auditors' audit reveals. Resistance from energy generators is also blocking progress.
The European Union’s vision of a local energy revolution is hitting serious roadblocks, a new report from the European Court of Auditors (ECA) revealed on Monday, as plans for citizens, local authorities and small businesses to create so-called “energy communities” – where they produce, share, and consume their own renewable energy – are moving far slower than promised.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
Citizens who belong to energy communities often express confusion about permits and legal steps and insufficient information and support, shattering dreams of energy self-sufficiency by way of shared rooftops or village-owned wind turbines.
The EU gave citizens the power to produce and trade their own energy in 2019, legally recognising energy communities and challenging the dominance of big utilities. But while the move was hailed as a step toward energy democracy, implementation has been held back by national regulators and entrenched industry interests.
One EU goal was for every municipality with more than 10,000 residents to host at least one renewable energy community by 2025. The European Commission has not yet reported on progress, but data gathered by EU auditors suggest the bloc has largely missed the target.
“As the EU races to meet its climate and energy goals, citizen-led energy remains a compelling idea – ideal in theory, but challenging in practice”, said João Leão, the ECA member responsible for the audit. “The EU now needs to sweep away legal hurdles and technical roadblocks to make it work effectively on the ground.”
Slow progress
The EU hoped energy community projects would help meet climate targets and even account for up to 21% of Europe’s solar and wind capacity by 2030. But the auditors say the bloc has been overly optimistic; there simply aren’t enough energy communities, and progress is lagging.
The report points to political and bureaucratic hurdles as key problems, a view shared by frustrated citizens who want to participate. It also notes that EU rules are unclear, as it’s often hard to understand what counts as an energy community, how to set one up or how to sell surplus electricity.
In apartment buildings, where half of the EU population lives, creating a new legal entity on top of existing management associations adds another layer of red tape, discouraging citizen participation.
The Croatian city of Poreč-Parenzo was a testbed for developing an energy community as part of an EU-funded project that ran from 2021 to 2024 and sparked interest among fellow municipalities.
"Unfortunately, due to the unsupportive legislative context, burdensome administrative procedures and lacking legal framework at national level, the voucher model concept is still to be tested in practice," reads a statement from the project's website.
Technical issues make things worse.
Grid congestion can delay or block new projects, and solar panels don’t always align with household energy needs, creating supply and demand issues.
"Part of the problem is that production and consumption patterns do not naturally match: solar panels generate most of their power around midday, while household demand peaks in the early morning and evening," the EU auditors stated.
Energy storage could solve this, but the European Commission has not prioritised it for energy communities, missing a chance to scale them up, the EU auditors say.
They urge the EU executive to simplify rules, provide incentives for citizens and vulnerable households and support storage solutions. Without political leadership, they argue, this “citizen-led energy revolution” risks remaining just a promise.
Flore Belin, Renewable Energy Policy Expert at the environmental organisation Climate Action Network Europe, said energy communities are still facing multiple barriers and will only deliver their full potential if EU countries implement the EU legal framework as a prerequisite.
"With the right regulatory and market conditions, energy communities provide a more democratic and fairer pathway that will bring us closer to meeting our climate ambitions, strengthen Europe’s energy resilience and help provide more stable and affordable energy bills,” Belin told Euronews.
A European Commission spokesperson welcomed the ECA's recommendations, calling for clarity for apartment owners, incentives for storage solutions, smart objectives, and robust registration and monitoring systems.
"The Commission will follow up on its recommendations in the context of the Citizens Energy Package, paying particular attention to ensuring inclusiveness and access to energy communities for all people," the spokesperson reacted.
Industry resistance
The embedded players in the sector are also slowing the development of energy communities.
Many energy communities face resistance from industry, usually through lobbying, regulatory pressure and control over grid infrastructure, which can slow the growth of citizen-led energy projects even when EU policy supports them.
One Dutch citizen cooperative, ValleiEnergie, recently tried to connect a community solar project near the city of Ede, but ran into serious grid barriers. The grid operator refused to allocate connection capacity, arguing that the electricity network was already at capacity.
At the same time, the cooperative had to pay a large deposit just to join the waiting list for a grid connection, with no guarantee of ever connecting to the grid.
“These deposits place energy cooperatives under severe financial pressure,” community members complained.
Yet there are some successful stories, too, even if limited, coming from Belgium and Denmark.
A Belgian project in the Flanders region recently celebrated one year of operations, with 72,000 co-operators who jointly own wind turbines, solar roofs and heating networks.
The Danish island of Samsø became famous for becoming 100% renewable through citizen-owned energy projects, including wind turbines and district heating systems, a central system that produces heat at one location and distributes it through insulated underground pipes to warm multiple buildings.
“People accepted the wind turbines because they owned them," said a local resident involved in the wind turbine cooperative. "When you have a share, the turbine becomes your neighbour.”