By Laura Davidescu
20/12/13 11:42 CET
| updated xx mn ago
| updated at xx
Expect your neck to twist and turn in 2014, while watching the Sino-Japanese tensions in the East China Sea spiralling upwards. Chances are high that Beijing and Tokyo will continue what seems to be the beginning of a cold war over the disputed seven square kilometres of the Diaoyu or Senkaku Islands, as they are respectively called by the Chinese and Japanese. These five uninhabited islets and three barren rocks situated in the East China Sea are at the heart of a territorial feud between the two most powerful Asian countries.
What is it about these tiny islets – the largest of which is home to just a few hundred feral goats, and an endangered species of mole – that makes them so special to both Japan and China?
Firstly, historical resentments and nationalist politics figure heavily in this territorial dispute. The Chinese claim the discovery and control of the islands from the 14th century while Japan controlled them from 1895 until its surrender at the end of World War II. The United States administered the islands from a 1945 to 1972, when the islands reverted to Japanese control, under the Okinawa Reversion Agreement between the United States and Japan. The People’s Republic of China disputed the proposed US handover of authority to Japan in 1971 and has asserted its claims to the islands since that time. Taiwan (Republic of China) also claims the Senkaku Islands.
There are observers who consider that the relationship between China and Japan encompasses Asia’s most dangerous case of historical obsession. Some analysts also say that, due to the link with atrocities committed during the Japanese invasion of China, in the second Sino-Japanese War, sentiments over the status of the Diaoyu/Senkaku islands run deeper in the Chinese psyche than any other territorial dispute in modern Chinese history.
Secondly, the small territory of the islets is close to key shipping lanes and rich fishing grounds.
But there’s another, much potent ingredient, that fuels this tensed face-off: energy. A United Nations-led geological survey in 1969 has found that large oil and natural gas reserves are at stake under the East China Sea, lying around the Senkakus and beyond. So the idea that there are vast resources just off the Japanese and Chinese coasts is a tremendous motivation for the intensity of their territorial dispute, as point out analyst of the Council on Foreign Relations, a think-tank based in Washington, D.C.
China is the world’s largest energy consumer, and its consumption is growing 6% each year, fast outstripping supply. As advances in deep-water drilling technology have put offshore oil and gas resources within reach for the first time, the result is, as the independent NGO International Crisis Group frames it, a race “to assert control over energy resources in disputed territories, before they are developed by a rival.”
Just how much oil and natural gas is at stake in the East China Sea is unclear. The territorial disputes have so far prevented any reliable survey. China estimates that one of the world’s largest natural gas deposits, containing some 250 trillion cubic feet, lies under the waters of the East China Sea. US energy analysts appreciate the “proven and probable” reserves there at only 1 to 2 trillion cubic feet – much less than the Gulf of Mexico, but still considerable.
Until recently, there was no way to exploit the riches of the East China Sea. The most promising petroleum prospect lies in water more than 2,500 meters deep, between the Chinese and Japanese continental shelves in the Okinawa Trough. And only in the past two decades has the oil industry developed the deepwater drilling technology.
Beyond the territorial-cum-energy contention and closely intertwined with it lie the fears triggered in the whole Eastern Asia by China’s more and more assertive positioning as a regional hegemony. In 2010, China started to take a more hardline approach towards Japan by increasing its aerial and law enforcement presence in disputed waters, to demonstrate its sovereignty. For Japan, 2010 was altogether an annus horribilis, known there as the “China shock”. That’s when China eclipsed Japan to become the world’s second-largest economy. This triggered an upsurge in Japanese nationalist sentiment, culminating in campaigns to name, and even to purchase, the disputed islands.
Chinese hardliners see these moves as Japan’s willingness to act as a proxy of the US in its efforts to contain China’s rise and expand US presence and influence in the Asia-Pacific region. In Japan, what is perceived as China’s determination to restructure the regional landscape is fuelling nationalist anxiety about Japan’s ability to defend its territory against a Chinese expansion.
No wonder, then, that on 17 December 2013, in Japan’s newly drafted National Security Strategy – the first comprehensive effort to articulate the ends and means for the country’s long-term security – while North Korea remains a serious challenge, the cabinet of the hawkish Prime Minister Shinzo Abe has clearly identified China and its maritime activities as Japan’s primary security concern. Named a “proactive strategy for maintaining peace,” the plan comes with a 5% increase in Japan’s military spending over the next five years.
China’s rise and “intensified activities” in and around Japan stand out in this new strategy. The Senkaku islands dispute with China has prompted considerable Japanese attention to its south-western defences. Whereas past defence statements have tended to focus on China’s growing military capabilities, this new strategy clearly focuses on Chinese behaviour. It identifies Chinese incursions into Japan’s territorial seas and airspace around the islands and Beijing’s announcement of the unilateral expanding of its air patrol zone – the so-called Air Defense Identification Zone – to include islands and rocks where sovereignty is disputed, as evidence of “attempts to change the status quo by coercion.”
As for the region as a whole, one cannot but wish that diplomacy, that “art of restraining power”, as former US State Secretary Henry Kissinger called it, finds its place in the fraught Sino-Japanese relations, before they grow to become a zero-sum game.
By Laura DavidescuMore about:
- 1Turkey: two journalists jailed over Syria smuggling reports
- 2All eyes on King Tut’s tomb in search for ancient Egypt’s lost Queen Nefertiti
- 3Another border fence in Europe ahead of crucial migration summit
- 4Tension in Turkey after pro-Kurdish lawyer is shot dead
- 5COP21: climate change provokes protests of all shapes and sizes
- 1Lavrov hits Turkey with more penalties, doubts commitment to war on “secret allies” ISIL
- 2Top Kurdish lawyer Tahir Elci shot dead in Turkey
- 3Turkey warns Russia not to ‘play with fire’ over downing of fighter jet
- 4Belgian police release new details about on-the-run fifth Paris suspect
- 5Mali: at least 3 dead in attack on UN peacekeepers base in Kidal
- 1Fate of pilots of downed Russian jet unclear
- 2Russia confirms Turks have shot down one of its planes on Syrian border
- 3Paris attacker Abdelhamid Abaaoud ‘returned to scene of shootings’
- 4Crimea: state of emergency declared
- 5Brussels remains on high alert: ‘multiple operations underway’ across Belgium
- 1Coordinated terror attacks leave dozens dead in Paris
- 2euronews live TV - News | euronews : the latest international news as video on demand
- 31000-year-old Bible found in Turkey
- 4Bomb and several shootings in central Paris – reports of fatalities and injuries
- 5International news | euronews, latest international news
- 6Police hunting Paris attacks mastermind battle with suspects in heart of Paris
- 7European Union News | euronews: latest breaking news and headlines about European Union
- 8world Weather | euronews: world ten day weather forecast
- 9Humans consume more than planet can produce on ‘Earth Overshoot Day’
- 10latest sci-tech news : euronews : the latest international news as video on demand
- 11Thousands in Bucharest blame corruption for Friday’s nightclub blaze
- 12‘Anonymous’ hackers’ group declares ‘war’ on ISIL
- 13‘Maxed-out:’ Jordan’s King Abdullah II’s frank warning over Syria crisis
- 14International breaking news | euronews online world breaking news in video
- 15Business news and finance news | euronews: international economic and finance news
- 16No Comment | euronews: international news images without commentary
- 17Latest News Bulletin
- 18Special Reports : euronews : the latest international news as video on demand
- 19Hope vs harsh reality: challenges to global education goals in the 21st century
- 20Terrorist threat on Europe’s rail network, according to German tabloid
Marathon great Radcliffe cleared of all doping charges
Black Friday in America: crowds in stores thin, but big at computers
French Foreign Minister foresees Syrian forces in the fight against ISIL
What is the EU’s drive for a circular economy all about?
And also… #1in5Muslims; not quite terrorism; Russia’s unlikely friendship
Wires > News
- 10:54 CET Syria monitor – Russian air strikes kill at least 18 in northwest
- 10:42 CET Body of Russian pilot in Turkey, preparing handover to Russia
- 10:31 CET Austria’s Faymann sees compromise in EU-Turkey talks – Kurier
- 08:42 CET Burkina Faso votes to choose first new leader in decades
- 07:19 CET Colorado shooting suspect said ‘no more baby parts’ – reports
- 06:28 CET Lie detectors, solitary: How South Korea screens refugees
- 03:11 CET Japan’s tiny refugee community urges Tokyo to open doors wider
- 01:06 CET EU hopes for Turkish help to slow migrants at summit