Find Us

U.S. Boy Scout scandal could be bigger than Catholic Church crisis

Image: Group Representing Children Abused In The Boy Scouts Holds News Conf
Attorney Stewart Eisenberg speaks during a press conference held by the Abused in Scouting legal team Aug. 6, 2019 in Washington. Copyright Win McNamee Getty Images
Copyright Win McNamee Getty Images
By Corky Siemaszko with NBC News U.S. News
Published on
Share this articleComments
Share this articleClose Button

The Abused in Scouting lawyers say they've identified 350 predator scoutmasters and represent 800 victims.


The Boy Scouts of America are continuing to cover-up a "pedophilia epidemic within their organization," a group of lawyers alleged Tuesday in a new lawsuit.

The Abused in Scouting lawyers said they've identified 350 previously unknown scoutmasters and volunteers who allegedly preyed on boys — and whose names were not known to law enforcement or in the BSA's internal database, which critics have called "perversion files."

"You can't look at these files and not come to the conclusion that this was a massive problem that was hidden," attorney Tim Kosnoff said at a press conference.

"We know that when a pedophile abuses a victim, it's not just one," added attorney Stewart Eisenberg. "So each of the 350 abusers have dozens of other victims who have not come forward."

The revelation that the lawyers had identified a small army who they claim are previously unknown scout sex abusers was contained in the lawsuit filed Monday in Philadelphia by a Pennsylvania man identified only as "J.D." who claims he was assaulted "hundreds" of times over a span of four years in the 1970s.

Win McNamee
Attorney Stewart Eisenberg speaks during a press conference held by the Abused in Scouting legal team Aug. 6, 2019 in Washington.Win McNamee

J.D., who lives in Wilkes-Barre, identified his attacker in the lawsuit as Paul Antosh, who also lives in the Pennsylvania city.

"I just heard about this lawsuit," Antosh, 62, told NBC News when reached by phone at the Poconos motel he manages.

Asked if the allegations are true, Antosh said, "I'm in the process of hiring counsel."

The complaint also names the Boy Scouts and the Penn Mountains Council.

"BSA knew for decades that sexual predators of boys had infiltrated scouting," the complaint states.

In response to questions from NBC News, the BSA said it was reviewing the spread sheet the Abused in Scouting lawyers sent them and "continuing to manually search paper records at the local level to see if we can identify more information about the additional alleged perpetrators identified in the plaintiff's attorneys list."

"We immediately investigated the limited information provided and our efforts have already resulted in approximately 120 reports to the lead law enforcement agency in each state with an accusation of abuse," the BSA said in emailed response. "We have also contacted local law enforcement for all the cases in which enough information was provided to identify the correct agency."

NBC News also asked the BSA whether Antosh was still involved in scouting. There was no immediate response to that question from the scouting organization.

The BSA, which has been hit with a raft of lawsuits by former scouts who said they were victimized, has acknowledged that it has maintained "ineligible volunteer files" since the 1920s that contained the names of alleged predators.

But the organization insists the internal database is a tool designed to keep sexual abusers out of the scouting and has denied hiding that names of scout leaders who have been accused of molesting boys from law enforcement.


Facing mounting legal costs from defending itself against lawsuits, the venerable nonprofit organization said in 2018 that it began considering filing for Chapter 11 bankruptcyprotection.

Founded in 1910 and long considered a bastion of traditional values, the BSA had as of 2016 more than 1.26 million Cub scouts, nearly 830,000 Boy Scouts, and around 960,000 adult volunteers.

Abused in Scouting (AIS) consists of lawyers from three different law firms who have banded together to take on the BSA.

Speaking at the National Press Club, Eisenberg said the Antosh case is the first of many lawsuits against the BSA to come. He said their 800 or so clients range in age from 14 to 88.


Most of the victims are from Texas, where the BSA is based, and states like Florida and North Carolina.

"Many of the victims can still recall the smell of the man who crawled into their bag," said attorney Andrew Van Arsdale. "These are powerful narratives."

Even more troubling, Kosnoff said, just four of the 800 victims "identify the same abuser."

"Everybody else is identifying another abuser," he said.


As for predator scoutmasters, "they're all over the country" and from a variety of professions, Eisenberg said.

Asked if any of the alleged scout abusers are still involved in scouting, Kosnoff said "We asked the BSA to help us identify these perpetrators. We've hit a stone wall with the Boy Scouts."

So the lawyers put out a TV spot in February urging victims to call their offices.

"It was slow at first," Kosnoff said. "But once the phones started ringing, they have not stopped."


Eisenberg called on Congress and local prosecutors to take a closer look at the BSA. He said they would also be happy to share what they have found with local law enforcement.

Share this articleComments

You might also like

Inside the Belgian church helping to welcome migrants to Europe

Trump secures Republican nomination after assassination attempt

US President Biden tests positive for COVID amid growing health concerns