Spies and governments cannot access phone data, top EU court rules - except for serious threats

The ruling said there would need to be a 'serious threat to national security' for such data to be accessed
The ruling said there would need to be a 'serious threat to national security' for such data to be accessed Copyright Ahn Young-joon/AP
Copyright Ahn Young-joon/AP
By Euronews
Share this articleComments
Share this articleClose Button

The European Court of Justice has issued its long-awaited ruling on whether data collection and retention by national governments aligns with EU law.


Data regulations in Europe should prevent spies and national governments from accessing data of phone and internet users, unless in circumstances of serious national security threats, the top EU court has ruled.

The judgement on Tuesday, from the European Court of Justice, was made in relation to a series of linked cases from France, the UK and Belgium - which have all experienced recent terror attacks and have upped surveillance as a result.

It added that it would allow for a limited timing of data retention where "a serious threat" was posed, and that data collection should be on an individual level.

A follow-up review should be conducted by an independent authority while for urgent cases, this should be carried out "promptly," the ruling said.

"Today’s judgement reinforces the rule of law in the EU," said Caroline Wilson, the legal director of Privacy International, a privacy campaign group that initially brought the case.

"In these turbulent times, it serves as a reminder that no government should be above the law.

"Democratic societies must place limits and controls on the surveillance powers of our police and intelligence agencies."

Share this articleComments

You might also like

EU top court invalidates EU-US data transfer agreement over surveillance concerns

Britain must abide by EU data protection rules after Brexit, says European Commission

Official election campaign underway in Hungary