Find Us


Analysis: How should the EU deal with 'totally incompatible' Hungary?

Hungary Politics Elections
Hungary Politics Elections Copyright Szilard Koszticsak/MTVA - Media Service Support and Asset Management Fund
Copyright Szilard Koszticsak/MTVA - Media Service Support and Asset Management Fund
By Darren McCaffrey, Political Editor
Published on Updated
Share this articleComments
Share this articleClose Button

Our political editor, Darren McCaffrey, asks how serious the EU is in its approach to Hungary.


Last Friday, the MEPs passed a resolution condemning the Hungarian government's actions during the coronavirus crisis as “totally incompatible with European values.”

It pleaded with the European Commission to look at whether Hungary had breached EU law, and urged the Council to put Article 7 (where EU countries can have their membership rights, such as voting, suspended because they don't meet the bloc's core values) back on the agenda - part of an ongoing effort to battle a seemingly authoritarian Viktor Orbán.

For the moment, MEPs' pleas are likely to go unheard. After all, in the middle of a pandemic, for Brussels helping to fight a virus and battling to keep countries' economics alive, ongoing rule of law issues in Budapest are going to struggle to get on the agenda.

But when this crisis passes - and it will - what can an increasingly frustrated and angry EU do?

Well, it can’t kick them out. While Article 50 allows for a country to leave, there is no such mechanism for forcing a member state out.

The Article 7 process, which suspends members' voting rights, is also unlikely to go anywhere. Another member state can simply veto it. Hungary has at least the backing of Poland and the Czech Republic.

The quickest and most-effective method could be to use the next EU budget to withhold financial payments, by qualified majority. Or allow the Commission to directly control the reallocation of funds, rather than funnelling them through Budapest. Hungary is a big recipient of these funds - reducing them would hurt. The European Union could also help foster and support democracy movements inside Hungary. The institutions could provide funding directly to municipalities and local governments as well as resources to trade unions, universities, and citizens' movements.

And finally, surely if Europe’s leaders were serious about sending a strong message to Orbán - the EPP, the union's largest political group would simply force out Fidesz.

Clearly, none of these decisions are easy, nor straightforward. But what’s the alternative? Sit back? Say nothing? Pretend it’s not happening? What would that then say about the EU’s values? Indeed, what would it say about the EU project itself?

Darren McCaffrey is Euronews' political editor.

If you would like to stay up to date with Euronews' coverage of the coronavirus crisis, please sign up to our newsletter, below.

Share this articleComments

You might also like

Austria closes Danube for shipping as deadly floods spread across central Europe

Tens of thousands take to the streets in show of support for Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán

Hungarian TV broadcasts first political debate in 18 years