Key moderate Republicans 'offended,' 'stunned' after Nadler accuses senators of 'cover-up'

Image: Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, arrives for the Senate impeachment tr
Sen. Lisa Murkowski, R-Alaska, arrives for the Senate impeachment trial on Jan. 23, 2020. Copyright Erin Scott Reuters
Copyright Erin Scott Reuters
By Dartunorro Clark and Geoff Bennett and Peter Alexander with NBC News Politics
Share this articleComments
Share this articleClose Button

Sens. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska and Susan Collins of Maine are two of the few Republicans who have expressed an openness to hearing from witnesses.


Two key moderate Senate Republicans criticized House Judiciary Chair Jerry Nadler, D-N.Y., on Thursday after he claimed this week that senators who do not support hearing from witnesses and entering documents into the trial would be complicit in a cover-up.

An aide to Sen. Lisa Murkowski of Alaska told NBC News that she was "offended" when Nadler, one of the seven House impeachment managers, made the accusation on the Senate floor.

Murkowski is one of a handful of moderate GOP senators who have expressed an openness to calling witnesses, including top Trump administration officials. For Democratic senators in need of four Republican votes to support them on the issue, Murkowski would be a critical vote.

Sen. Susan Collins of Maine, another Republican who has been open to witnesses, wrote a note to Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts that took issue with Nadler's remark, according to a spokesperson.

"Well, I was stunned by Congressman Nadler's approach, and it reminded me that if we were in a normal debate in the Senate that the rule will be invoked to strike the words of the Senator, for imputing another Senator in this case," she said in a statement. "So, I did write a note raising the issue of whether there had been a violation of the rules of the Senate, and I gave that note to Laura Dove, and well shortly thereafter the Chief Justice did admonish both sides and I was glad that he did." (Dove is the Senate majority secretary.)

Despite her objection to the remark, Collins said it will not affect her votes during the trial.

Nadler criticized Republicans shortly after midnight on Wednesday toward the end of a marathon day of debate over the rules of the impeachment trial. Nadler's comments came as he was making the case for calling former national security adviser John Bolton to testify. Other top Democrats also excoriated Republicans for being unwilling to have new witnesses and documents in the trial.

"The president is on trial in the Senate, but the Senate is on trial in the eyes of the American people. Will you vote to allow all the relevant evidence to be presented here? Or will you betray your pledge to be an impartial juror?" Nadler said. "Will you bring Ambassador Bolton here? Will you permit us to present you with the entire record of the president's misconduct? Or will you instead choose to be complicit in the president's cover-up? So far, I'm sad to say, I see a lot of senators voting for a cover-up, voting to deny witnesses, an absolutely indefensible vote, obviously a treacherous vote."

Other Republicans, such as Sen. Ron Johnson of Wisconsin and Senate Judiciary Chairman Lindsey Graham of South Carolina, also criticized Nadler's comment.

"If the Democrats are smart, they won't put Jerry Nadler on the field again," Johnson said. "He was so out of line. It's offensive accusing us of a cover-up."

Share this articleComments