This content is not available in your region

Hungary used malware 'to spy on critical journalists and politicians', claims media investigation

Facebook has sued the Israeli NSO Group for allegedly targeting some 1,400 users of its WhatsApp service with its spyware.
Facebook has sued the Israeli NSO Group for allegedly targeting some 1,400 users of its WhatsApp service with its spyware.   -   Copyright  AP Photo/Martin Meissner
By Euronews with AP, AFP

European political dissidents, human rights activists and journalists are among thousands worldwide being spied on by malware sold to authoritarian regimes, a media investigation has claimed.

Journalists were allegedly spied upon in Hungary and France and the revelations have prompted calls for inquiries.

The Pegasus Project investigation, released on Monday, is based on a list of more than 50,000 mobile phone numbers believed to be targeted by the malware by the Israel-based NSO Group and leaked to the Paris-based nonprofit Forbidden stories and human rights group Amnesty International.

The military-grade malware infects phones, allowing the operator to access messages, photos, emails, and location data as well as surreptitiously control the device's microphones and cameras.

A consortium of 16 media organisations was able to identify more than 1,000 individuals in 50 countries who were allegedly selected for potential surveillance by NSO clients.

These include more than 600 politicians and officials, dozens of business executives and human rights activists, several heads of states and over 180 journalists, including Cecilio Pineda, a Mexican journalist who extensively covered crime, social issues and corruption. He was shot dead in March 2017.

'Completely unacceptable'

Journalists working for The Associated Press, Reuters, CNN, The Wall Street Journal, Le Monde and The Financial Times, also featured on the list. At least five Hungarian journalists are also believed to have been spied on by the authorities.

Ten Hungarian lawyers as well as one opposition politician were also allegedly targeted by the country's right-wing government of Prime Minister Viktor Orban.

Three members of Hungary's parliamentary national security committee called on Monday for an emergency session to question government agencies on their potential involvement in the spying.

Janos Stummer, the committee's chairman and a lawmaker from the right-wing opposition party Jobbik, said that the surveillance described by the investigation is “not permissible in a state governed by the rule of law.”

A majority of seats on the committee are held by governing party lawmakers who could potentially block the inquiry by boycotting the session but Stummer said that "staying silent would essentially be an acknowledgement that the government is indeed involved in this".

The Hungarian government's international communications office told Euronews that the country "is a democratic state governed by the rule of law, and as such, and when it comes to any individual it has always acted and continues to act in accordance with the law in force".

"In Hungary, state bodies authorised to use covered instruments are regularly monitored by governmental and non-governmental institutions," it added.

Over in France, the investigative media outlet, Mediapart, announced it has filed a complaint with the prosecutor's office. Two of their journalists, including co-founder Edwy Plenel, were listed as among the potential targets. They accuse the Moroccan intelligence services of spying on them.

The satirical weekly newspaper Le Canard Enchainé also announced that they "are going to file a complaint" as several of their journalists also featured on the list.

Gabriel Attal, the spokesperson for the French government, said in reaction to the investigation on Monday that "these are extremely shocking facts, and, if they are true, are extremely serious."

"We are extremely attached to the freedom of the press, so it is very serious to have manipulations, techniques that aim to harm the freedom of journalists, their freedom to investigate, to inform," he told France Info radio.

European Commission chief Ursula von der Leyen told reporters in Prague on Monday that the claims have "to be verified" but that, if true, "it is completely unacceptable."

"Freedom of the press is a core value of the European Union," Von der Leyen stressed.

'Weapon of choice for repressive governments'

The most numbers on the list, 15,000, were for Mexican phones, with a large share in the Middle East. NSO Group's spyware has been implicated in targeted surveillance chiefly in the Middle East and Mexico. Saudi Arabia is reported to be among NSO clients. Also on the lists were phones in countries including France, Hungary, India, Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan and Pakistan.

People close to Jamal Khashoggi, the Saudi Washington Post columnist brutally murdered at the Saudi embassy in Istanbul in October 2018, feature on the list. They include his fiancé, Hatice Elatr, his son, Abdullah, and wife, Hanan Elatr.

"The Pegasus Project lays bare how NSO's spyware is a weapon of choice for repressive governments seeking to silence journalists, attacks activists and crush dissent, placing countless lives in peril," Agnes Callamard, secretary-general of Amnesty International, said in a statement.

"The number of journalists identified as targets vividly illustrates how Pegasus is used as a tool to intimidate critical media. It is about controlling the pubic narrative, resisting scrutiny, and suppressing any dissenting voice," she added.

NSO Group denied that it has ever maintained “a list of potential, past or existing targets.” In a separate statement, it called the Forbidden Stories report “full of wrong assumptions and uncorroborated theories.”

The company reiterated its claims that it only sells to “vetted government agencies” for use against terrorists and major criminals and that it has no visibility into its customers’ data. Critics call those claims dishonest — and have provided evidence that NSO directly manages the high-tech spying. They say the repeated abuse of Pegasus spyware highlights the nearly complete lack of regulation of the private global surveillance industry.

The source of the leak — and how it was authenticated — was not disclosed. While a phone number's presence in the data does not mean an attempt was made to hack a device, the consortium said it believed the data indicated potential targets of NSO's government clients.

NSO targeted by lawsuits

The consortium's “Pegasus Project” reporting bolsters accusations that not just autocratic regimes but democratic governments, including India and Mexico, have used NSO Group's Pegasus spyware for political ends.

In 2019, WhatsApp and its parent company Facebook sued NSO Group in U.S. federal court in San Francisco, accusing it of exploiting a flaw in the popular encrypted messaging service to target — with missed calls alone — some 1,400 users. NSO Group denies the accusations.

The Israeli company was sued the previous year in Israel and Cyprus, both countries from which it exports products. The plaintiffs include Al-Jazeera journalists, as well as other Qatari, Mexican and Saudi journalists and activists who say the company’s spyware was used to hack them.

NSO Group also denies involvement in elaborate undercover operations uncovered by The AP in 2019 in which shadowy operatives targeted NSO critics including a Citizen Lab researcher to try to discredit them.

Last year, an Israeli court dismissed an Amnesty International lawsuit seeking to strip NSO of its export license, citing insufficient evidence.

NSO Group is far from the only merchant of commercial spyware. But its behaviour has drawn the most attention, and critics say that is with good reason.