It's time to end our love affair with toilet roll. What’s wrong with a bidet?

Manufacturing toilet paper does a lot of environmental damage.
Manufacturing toilet paper does a lot of environmental damage. Copyright Unsplash
Copyright Unsplash
By Rosie Frost
Share this articleComments
Share this articleClose Button

Pandemic induced panic-buying has got us all considering toilet paper alternatives in our time of need.


Every year nearly €75 billion worth of toilet paper is bought around the world. According to Statista, that’s around 8kg per person. Understandably, it is an essential item on most people’s shopping lists, but some countries use a lot more than others. Americans, for instance, go through an average of 57 sheets every day.

That’s a whole lot of paper. Used once, for obvious reasons, and then flushed away, it’s not something we are keen on recycling either making it pretty much the ultimate single-use item. Shortages in many parts of the world due to COVID-19 panic buying have had us all searching for potentially questionable alternatives, but should we be looking to ditch toilet roll altogether in the face of a different global crisis?

Alberto Pezzali /AP
Toilet paper attached to a drone as part of funny stunt making light of toilet paper shortages in the UK.Alberto Pezzali /AP

Wiping out our forests

Manufacturing sheets of this trusty bathroom staple has a devastating impact on the environment. A report from Greenpeace in 2017 discovered that logging linked to toilet paper had severely damaged Sweden’s Great Northern Forest. The National Resources Defense Council (NDRC) and also released a report more recently called “The Issue With Tissue”, in 2019, which explains how Canada’s boreal forests are being similarly destroyed by America’s desire for luxurious 3-ply.

The majority of these trees are hundreds of years old and cannot easily be replanted to restore the ecosystem. “Most Americans probably do not know that the toilet paper they flush away comes from ancient forests,” says Anthony Swift, director of the Canada project at NDRC. “Maintaining the Canadian boreal forest is vital to avoiding the worst impacts of climate change.”

Important biodiversity is under threat from ‘clear-cutting’, a process which removes nearly all of the trees from an area. This has a knock-on effect for the rest of the forest’s ecology leading to flooding, habitat loss and the death of plants and animals that use tree canopies as shelter. Indigenous communities who call the region home also face problems as the natural resources they rely on to live are depleted.

All for the purpose of keeping our backsides clean.

Negative perceptions of recycled rolls mean that we’re more likely to reach for products made from the virgin tree pulp sourced from these trees. Where other industries are looking to up their recycling initiatives, Ethical Consumer found that the world’s biggest suppliers of toilet paper were actually increasing the number of trees being chopped down in a search for softness. Their explanation? We just aren’t buying enough of the recycled stuff.

Sweden's ancient forests.Unsplash

What’s the problem with recycled paper?

While conventional toilet paper wipes out trees at an astonishing rate, plenty of recycled options do exist out there. They can be made using both waste from other paper manufacturing processes but also from the junk mail, cardboard boxes and milk cartons that end up in our recycling bins.

The problem lies with the fact that recycled materials don’t seem to give us the same quality as the less environmentally friendly options. The long paper fibres needed to make paper in repeated contact with some, very delicate, parts of the human body luxuriously soft just don’t survive the recycling process. That just doesn’t cut in a market where comfort is the consumer’s main concern. Another worry is that post-consumer sources for recycled paper may contain BPA, a chemical that has been linked to a number of health problems.

A whole host of startups have emerged in the last few years seeking to solve the negative image of recycled brands. Companies like Who Gives a Crap and No. 2 are making rolls made from materials that they claim are more sustainable and marketing them as something to look good stacked on the back of your toilet. Subscription services like these hope to provide a more modern, convenient way of getting a hold of something to wipe with.

The crowdfunded brand, Who Gives a Crap, solves the problem of softness and sustainability by offering both recycled and bamboo versions of its paper. Bamboo is considered to be a relatively environmentally friendly source of paper fibres. The fast-growing grass regenerates from its own roots, doesn’t need fertilising, and produces 35 per cent more oxygen than tree equivalents.

Who Gives A Crap offer a sustainable toilet roll subscription service.Unsplash

Would you use a Bidet?

With stocks of the soft, white stuff running low, many people are discovering completely paper-free ways to keep themselves clean. Before you start reaching for the wet wipes, kitchen towels or even the medieval luxury of the goose neck (yes, that really happened), plain old water is always an option.

Bidets are a common bathroom fixture in some countries around the world and have been a mandatory addition for Italian toilets since 1975. Northern Europe seems to have fallen out of love with the washing our rear ends and asking an American what a bidet is, is likely to result in a quizzical look. But with the pandemic causing shelves to be cleared of hundreds of rolls, those already clued into this hygiene revolution are sitting pretty.

Miki Agrawal, founder of a toilet attachment brand popular with millennials, TUSHY, says that the current shortage could be the tipping point that gets people to finally ditch toilet paper altogether. “Since the late 1800s, we have been led to believe that toilet paper does the job, but all it does is cost us money every month (to the tune of billions of dollars per year if you add us all together), kills millions of trees per year and causes chronic infections and disease down there like UTIs, hemorrhoids and fissures.”

Using a bidet is an unexpected way to cut your water use.TUSHY

She explains that the company’s goal has always been to save the millions of trees worth of paper being flushed down the toilet every day. Weirdly, because the toilet paper manufacturing process is so water-intensive, switching to a bidet could reduce your water usage as well. Making a single roll of paper uses around 140 litres of water and most people go through one and a half rolls a week. Tushy claims that each use of their device requires less than half a litre, meaning you need just under 5 litres a week to keep you clean.

Our toilet habits are not something we often consider the environmental ramifications of, but as urgency makes us more open to unconventional options, paper made from virgin wood could take a back seat. Many of the sustainable subscription services are currently sold out and TUSHY has seen a tenfold increase in its projected sales for the year. Time will tell if, when the pandemic ends, people stick with sustainable alternatives for the sake of the trees.

Share this articleComments

You might also like