Calling it a battle of David and Goliath, Irish fast food chain Supermac’s won a battle against American giant McDonald's to have the use of the iconic Big Mac trademark cancelled.
ADVERTISEMENTThe “Big Mac” trademark is not exclusive to McDonald’s anymore, at least not in the EU.
In a landmark ruling, McDonald's has lost the right to the trademark 'Big Mac' across the bloc to the Irish fast-food chain Supermac.
“This is the end of McBully,” said Supermac’s founder Pat McDonagh in a statement after the European Union Intellectual Property Office (EUIPO) ruled McDonald’s did not prove genuine use of the contested trademark.
It comes as sweet revenge for the Irish company who said they faced off with the American multinational. Supermac claimed it was prevented from entering different markets and will now be able to do so after the ruling.
“[McDonald's] trademarked the SnackBox, which is one of Supermac’s most popular products, even though the product is not actually offered by them. We have been saying for years that they have been using trademark bullying,” McDonagh said.
In 2015, Supermac’s submitted a formal request to EUIPO to cancel the “Big Mac” name and “Mc” trademarks that McDonald’s had registered for certain products. It was also decided that McDonald’s bear the costs for the revocation, according to the company’s spokesperson, Padraic O Neachtain.
McDonagh called the judgement a victory for small businesses all over the world, comparing it to a biblical story.
“We knew when we took on this battle that it was a David versus Goliath scenario but just because McDonald's has deep pockets and we are relatively small in context doesn’t mean we weren’t going to fight our corner,” McDonagh said in a statement.
He went on to say: “The original objective of our application to cancel was to shine a light on the use of trademark bullying by this multinational to stifle competition. We have been saying for years that they have been using trademark bullying.”
But the American fast-food giant said they're not giving up and intend to appeal the decision, which they are confident will be overturned.
“We are disappointed in the EUIPO’s decision and believe this decision did not take into account the substantial evidence submitted by McDonald’s proving use of our BIG MAC mark throughout Europe," a McDonald's spokesperson said in an e-mailed statement to Euronews. "McDonald’s owns full and enforceable trademark rights for the mark “BIG MAC” throughout Europe."
Expert opinion: Why did McDonald's lose?
According to intellectual property solicitor Carissa Kendall-Windless from law firm EIP, McDonald's could have prevented this ruling if they provided a better audit trail.
"No matter how big or small your company is, if you’re filing an application for a trademark and your intention is to build a brand, you need to be using your trademark in conjunction with those products and services you’re seeking protection for, " Kendall-Windless told Euronews.
Adding, "you don’t need to just use, you need to really document that use because if you don’t, you open yourself up to vulnerability, being attacked and your mark being cancelled."
McDonald’s has historically been “extremely litigious” in the area of trademark law and typically does not lose, according to Willajeanne McLean, a law professor at the University of Connecticut.
In 1993, McDonald’s won a court order blocking a dentist in New York from selling services under the name “McDental” and in 2016, McDonald’s defeated an effort by a Singapore company to register ‘MACCOFFEE’ as an EU trademark.