By Jesús Aguado and Stefanie Eschenbacher
SANTANDER, Spain/MEXICO CITY (Reuters) – Santander has offered to take full control of its Mexican business through a 2.6 billion euro (£2.24 billion) all-share deal as the Spanish bank chases potentially higher returns available from Latin America.
The deal proposed on Friday, which was broadly welcomed by analysts but described as “oppressive” by a major investor, will unwind Santander’s listing of 25 percent of the bank on the Mexican stock exchange in 2012. The move is part of efforts to focus more on emerging economies while cutting costs to counter squeezed margins in mature European markets.
While record-low interest rates have prevailed across the euro zone for the past 10 years, benchmark rates in Mexico stand at 8.25 percent, the highest since the 2008 global financial crisis.
The Mexico deal will also bring Santander head to head with Spain’s second-largest bank BBVA, which makes about 40 percent of its earnings from Mexico.
“(The deal) is an opportunity to gain exposure to a diversified, global bank with growing and more predictable results than those of comparable peers,” Chairwoman Ana Botin told shareholders at Santander’s annual general meeting.
Earnings from Mexico are expected to rise to 10 percent of group profit, up from 8 percent, Botin said. Latin America as a whole accounts for 43 percent of the Spanish bank’s earnings.
At least one investor, Bill Kanko, president of Black Creek Investment Management, took a dim view of the plan. The Canadian asset manager is the fourth-largest investor in Banco Santander Mexico, excluding the parent, according to Refinitiv data.
“This is a ‘squeeze-out’ or ‘take-under’, and we have little recourse,” Kanko said. He said Santander’s offer carried only a small premium that did not fully compensate minority shareholders whose investments he said “subsidized” a spending program that started in 2017.
Banco Santander Mexico said in 2016 it would invest $736 million in branches and technology. Kanko said that had depressed earnings in the short term but “made sense to us longer term.”
“The growth opportunity in Mexican banking services, the repair of their balance sheet, the appointment of a highly respected CEO, the efficiency measures of the bank, and the governance of the parent company – how ironic – were the underpinnings of our investment thesis.”
Kanko said Black Creek invested in the bank in early 2014 via American depositary receipts, shares in a foreign company that are traded in the United States.
Reuters contacted the 15 largest investors in Banco Santander Mexico, excluding the parent, according to Refinitiv Eikon data, for comment. Several, including BlackRock, Vanguard and JPMorgan Asset Management, declined to comment. Others did not immediately respond.
The Mexico plan overshadowed Friday’s shareholder meeting, where some investors criticised management handling of an aborted process to hire Italian banker Andrea Orcel as chief executive. In an unusual U-turn on such a major appointment, the bank said in January that it could not meet his pay expectations.
“It’s a good decision that you stopped it, but it is a mega-disclosure accident,” investor Hans Martin told the meeting, also asking if Jose Antonio Alvarez would remain as CEO for the foreseeable future.
“Will you (Alvarez) be with us for a certain time or do we have to look every day on the internet (to see) if you are (still) there?” Martin asked.
Mexico is a highly profitable market, where Santander has set a mid-term target of 19-21 percent for the underlying return on tangible equity.
“In our view this transaction is a step in the right direction to improve Santander’s focus on high-growth markets,” Deutsche Bank analysts said.
At 1248 GMT Santander’s shares were up almost 3 percent.
However, analysts also said Santander’s timing could be less than ideal after a recent slowdown in Mexico’s economic growth.
Santander, which holds about 75 percent of its Mexican business, said it would issue up to 572 million new shares, equivalent to up 3.5 pct of Santander’s market capitalisation, to finance the deal.
The new issuance is worth about 2.6 billion euros based on Thursday’s close, according to Refinitiv data.
The euro zone’s biggest lender in terms of market value will offer 0.337 shares for 1 share of Santander Mexico and 1.685 shares per share to holders of Santander Mexico ADS.
Santander said the exchange ratio represented a 14 percent premium to the closing prices of Banco Santander and Santander Mexico shares on April 11.
Santander expects the transaction to have a return on investment of approximately 14.5 percent, to be neutral on earnings per share and to contribute positively to the group’s core Tier-1 capital ratio.
(Reporting by Jesús Aguado in SANTANDER, Jose Elias Rodriguez in MADRID and Stefanie Eschenbacher in MEXICOCITY; Editing by Jane Merriman/David Goodman and Grant McCool)