This content is not available in your region

Chinese judges make rare defence of death penalty amid Western criticism

Access to the comments Comments
By Reuters

By Christian Shepherd

BEIJING (Reuters) – Top judges from China’s Supreme People’s Court have made a rare defence of the death penalty, with one saying “a life for a life” is ingrained among the people, and backed “social credit” blacklists as necessary to made people repay their debts.

President Xi Jinping has urged widespread reforms to the legal system, pledging to tackle miscarriages of justice and to strengthen the leadership of the ruling Chinese Communist Party over the courts.

But rights groups say the reforms fail to ensure fair trials, guard against rights abuses or restrict use of the death penalty. Amnesty International said on Tuesday that China is failing to restrict the use of the death penalty to the most serious crimes only, in line with international norms.

Despite efforts to reduce executions, China could not abolish the system which would risk angering a public that overwhelmingly supports its use, Li Xiao, a top judge, told reporters late on Thursday, during a promotional visit to the Supreme Court.

“For thousands of years, the idea of ‘a life for a life’ has been deeply ingrained among ordinary folk… If we released the figure, then ordinary folk would say too few were killed,” she said.

The Supreme People’s Court is responsible for review and approval of all death sentences before they are carried out.

Beijing considers the number of people executed in China each year to be state secret. International human rights organisations estimate the figure at around 2,000.

Judges also defended China’s nascent social credit system, saying that restrictions on luxury purchases, such as flights or high-speed train tickets, are a good way to get people to fulfil their court-mandated debt repayments.

China’s lack of a system for dealing with individual bankruptcy, as there is in the United States, means that such restrictions are necessary, Liu Guixiang, another judge, told reporters.

“If I am bankrupt and say that I cannot repay my debts, then I enjoy a luxurious, extravagant life day to day – I reckon you would be put in jail for that in the West,” Liu said.

The court’s blacklists for individuals who fail to carry out court-mandated tasks, such as repaying debts, are a part of a plan to build a “social credit” system to punish citizens more effectively for illegal behaviour and encourage actions deemed socially beneficial.

The system is being tried out in a handful of cities and punishments are largely linked to industry-specific blacklists, but some observers have expressed concerns that it may be abused to compel people or companies to toe the party line.

(Reporting by Christian Shepherd; Editing by Nick Macfie)