'Another foreign agent': Russian court orders closure of country's oldest human rights NGO, Memorial

Access to the comments Comments
By Aleksandar Brezar  with AP, AFP
Police officers detain a demonstrator holding a poster reading "Hands off the Memorial, freedom for political prisoners" as other people gather in front of the Supreme Court
Police officers detain a demonstrator holding a poster reading "Hands off the Memorial, freedom for political prisoners" as other people gather in front of the Supreme Court   -   Copyright  AP Photo/Pavel Golovkin

Russia’s Supreme Court on Tuesday ruled that the country’s oldest and most prominent human rights organization should be closed down — a move that stirred up much public outrage and is the latest step in a months-long crackdown on rights activists, independent media, and opposition supporters.

The Prosecutor General’s Office last month petitioned the Supreme Court to revoke the legal status of Memorial, an international human rights group that rose to prominence for its studies of political repression in the Soviet Union and currently encompasses more than 50 smaller groups in Russia and abroad.

A movement rather than a singular organisation, Memorial founded 23 branches throughout the former USSR between 1987 and 1990, eventually growing to its current size and counting more than 60 offices over the course of the past three decades.

1975 Nobel Peace Prize winner and civil liberties advocate Andrey Sakharov — also known for the eponymous prize given out by the European Parliament to those dedicated to human rights and freedoms — was one of the NGOs founders.

Facing pushback that included raids on their offices and confiscation of materials, Memorial fought hard to promote truth about the historical past of totalitarian regimes through school programs, publications, and documentary films, and by allowing public access to documentation from the likes of KGB and FSB.

By 2005, it created a database containing information on more than 1,3 million victims of political repression in the Soviet Union.

Memorial was also one of several NGOs that persuaded the Russian state to institutionalise the remembrance of those deemed dissidents of the Soviet regime, leading the state to declare October 30 as Remembrance Day for the Victims of Political Repression.

However, the NGO fell increasingly out of favour with Russian president Vladimir Putin after his controversial re-election to a third term, following constitutional changes, in 2012.

The court on Tuesday ruled in favour of the prosecution, which charged at the hearing that Memorial “creates a false image of the USSR as a terrorist state, whitewashes and rehabilitates Nazi criminals”, claiming that the list of dissidents contains "Nazi offenders with blood of Soviet citizens on their hands".

After its Moscow-based Human Rights Centre was first designated a “foreign agent” in 2014, the same status befell Memorial two years later — a label that implies additional government scrutiny and carries strong pejorative connotations.

In their lawsuit to shut it down, prosecutors alleged that the group repeatedly violated regulations obliging it to mark itself as a foreign agent and tried to conceal the designation.

The aim of the designation is to limit their access to and collaboration with the Russian public, who might fear state repercussions. For media outlets designated as foreign agents, it carries the consequence of a significant decrease in advertising revenue as companies shy away from angering government institutions.

The Human Rights Centre was ordered shut by a Moscow court on Wednesday with judge Mikhail Kazakov saying the court had "decided to grant the prosecutor's request to dissolve the Memorial rights organisation and all related entities".

Memorial and its supporters have maintained the accusations are politically motivated, and the organization's leaders have vowed to continue their work even if the court shuts it down.

Pressure on the group has sparked public outrage, with many prominent figures speaking out in its support this month.

Journalist and 2021 Nobel Peace Prize laureate Dmitry Muratov, former Soviet leader and another Peace Prize laureate Mikhail Gorbachev, the Moscow Helsinki Group, and Alexander Solzhenitsyn's widow Natalia Solzhenitsyna all criticised the decision.

Lyudmila Petrushevskaya, one of Russia’s most prominent contemporary writers, announced that she was returning the Russian State Prize she received in 2004 in protest against the decision.


Several people were reportedly detained on Tuesday for picketing the courthouse.

In recent months, the Russian government has designated a number of independent media outlets, journalists, and human rights groups as “foreign agents”. At least two disbanded to avoid a tougher crackdown.